I was out of town when metro area Unitarian Universalist
ministers began their online reaction to
Lisa Miller’s March 22 “On Faith”column in The Washington Post.
The headline assigned to her piece would have
stopped just about anyone turning the pages on that Saturday morning: “Many
Unitarians Would Prefer That Their Polyamory Activists Keep Quiet.”
Whether you read her opinion or not - and
especially if you were unfamiliar with Unitarian Universalism - your understanding
of us might have been shaped in just the few seconds it took to absorb the
announcement made by that ten word headline.
One of my colleagues and two UU members from area congregations had
their letters to the editor published the following week (
WaPo, 3/30), but common wisdom is that letters of this sort never
leave much of an impression on readers.
Besides
being poorly written and researched and - in several places - simply wrong,
I’ve been wondering what the point of the column was.
What was her goal?
Was there purpose to her shoddy
journalism?
What was she trying to
accomplish?
This was the kind of opinion
writing I expect from a Rupert Murdoch publication, not
The Washington Post with whom I don’t always agree but generally
maintains a reputation for good journalism.
Yes, it was disappointing especially when there was so much more that
could have been said about Unitarian Universalism that would have been
accurate, provocative and stimulating!
As I said, I was out of town when the column appeared and when the call
went out for a response.
But also, other
things needed my attention.
If I had not
been consumed in my ministry with you, I might have written about one sentence
in particular with which I took exception:
“The debate
[over polyamory] makes the whole denomination look silly.”
Silly as in “foolish, stupid, unintelligent,
idiotic, brainless, mindless, witless, imbecilic, doltish, irresponsible, mad,
erratic, unstable, childish, empty-headed, weak-minded, crazy, loopy, screwy ...” (Oxford Dictionary). You get the
point.
Our faith is silly?
Here’s just one of the objections to her
declaration: There is no debate, at least not one that I or any of my
colleagues know about.
I know of no UU
congregation that is debating the issues of which she speaks.
One of her sources is a six year old sermon
given at the UU Fellowship in
Chesterton,
MD by someone I’ve never heard
of.
That, and her other sources, fall
far short of any reasonable measure of “the whole denomination” (besides, we’re
not a denomination nor are we “Unitarian,” but Unitarian Universalist).
But as I’ve said, I had other things on my
mind.
While
The WaPo journalist was writing her
misguided column about our alleged silly congregational life, many at UUCA were
in shock over and mourning the tragic death of Marine Lance Corporal Taylor
Wild whose memorial service saw 500+ standing shoulder to shoulder in our
sanctuary.
That same week saw your
ministers praying with
and sharing
healing words of affirmation and courage with 25 people who came forward during
the Tuesday AWAKE service.
On Thursday night, twenty UUCA members and friends concluded a four week
conversation on “Life and Death,” in which the personal authenticity and
vulnerability was moving beyond words.
On Saturday evening, UUCA opened its doors for our annual Passover Seder,
the traditional meal shared while remembering the liberation and exodus of Jews
from political and spiritual oppression.
This Saturday, we will host another memorial service for former church
members whose fifty year old daughter succumbed to cancer after fighting it for
several years.
So you see, it was hard
for me - and others of the Ministry Team - to get too worked up about Lisa
Miller’s column suggesting we were “silly.”
UUCA was deep into the ministry and meaning that shapes and sustains
life.
If you
detect a slight edge to my words, you’re right.
I’ve grown quite tired of outsiders - and insiders, as in our own
members and friends - whose misunderstanding of Unitarian Universalism leads
them to conclusions and then utterances that are at best wrong and at worst
offensive. My hope and prayer is to see
the day when we no longer must endure the silly ignorance of the uninformed.
Take care
and see you soon,
Fred